DAOs in court? Curve Finance ponders enforcing license over rival Saddle

Published at: June 16, 2021

Square peg, meet round hole: a decentralized autonomous organization is pondering taking a rival fork to court. 

Earlier today, a member of the Curve Finance community made a post in Curve’s governance forum titled “Enforce Curve’s IP Rights.”

“Curve has proven incredibly popular, with over $10B deposited, hundreds of millions in daily volume, and around $1M/week in earnings to veCRV holders. This places it among the top of all exchanges in crypto today, even rivaling publicly-traded CEX’s,” the post reads. “[...] Those CEX’s protect their IP on behalf of their shareholders and there is no reason why Curve, just by virtue of its DAO organization, should not protect itself for the benefit of veCRV holders too.”

The target of the IP enforcement in this case would be Saddle. Saddle — which the official Curve Twitter handle characterized as a “line-by-line translation from one language to another,” potentially a violation of Curve’s license — launched in January this year to significant fanfare and with major VC backing. It also enabled a handful of wild arbitration trades on the day of launch, which some characterized as an exploit.

Some observers immediately griped that, much like Uniswap v3’s business licenses, such an action would not be consistent with DeFi’s open-source ethos.

RELATED: Curve Finance’s new release positions project for AMM takeover

However, Sam Miorelli, a cybersecurity specialist by day and a budding protocol politician by night who authored the proposal, argues that protecting the value of intellectual work is a fundamental right:

“IP is an important part of hundreds of years of innovation in literally every aspect of society and the economy. Decentralization doesn't change that creators have a natural right (protected by law in effectively every jurisdiction) to the fruits of those creations.”

Protecting the moat

While Saddle has been live for nearly six months and has largely failed to eat into Curve’s TVL (Curve is currently the 2nd-largest DeFi protocol with $10.49 billion in total value locked, while Saddle sits at just under $59 million), part of what spurred Miorelli into action may be a major depositor taking their pools to Saddle. 

When’s the first IP infringement lawsuit? As a $veCRV holder I want @CurveFinance to assert and protect its position aggressively. https://t.co/XjNE3uF7t2

— Astronaut Sam Miorelli (@SamMiorelli) June 15, 2021

Alchemix — a protocol that offers loans of synthetic assets based on future yield from assets deposited into the Yearn.Finance protocol — recently opted to start an alETH pool on Saddle, though their alUSD pool is on Curve and is the third-largest single pool on the platform. The choice was made in the context of a larger, ongoing tension between Yearn and Curve over CRV reward token emissions and dumping. 

The specifics of how to move forward to protect their moat are tremendously complex, however. “Charlie,” a member of Cruve’s core team told Cointelegraph that the Curve DAO has a licence granted by Swiss Stake GmbH, while the Curve DAO itself is not a legal entity and has an open source license.

Moreover, it’s unclear if Saddle likewise holds a legal entity, if VC investors could be liable, or if trying to enforce the license would make CRV a security.

The team member who manages the Curve Twitter handle speculated that, due to these complications and the costs, moving forward may not make sense (regardless of how badly they may want to do it):

It's also a question whether it makes sense to proceed from business perspective. Suing a top tier VC backed startup sounds extremely exciting in principle, but not when it is a worthless one

— Curve Finance (@CurveFinance) June 16, 2021

Miorelli noted that regardless of whether Curve moves forward with legal action, “a lot of DAOs need to pay more attention to this topic” because keeping “profits with a DAO instead of going to well heeled VCs, is central to the DeFi ethos - even when it takes something like courts to do it.”

Ultimately, the decision to litigate will be one about principles before possible monetary rewards, he added:

“Sometimes those rights are easy or profitable to enforce, sometimes they're not. But profitability is a question you ask after you first decide ‘do I want to even try enforcing my rights?’ That's the crux of my proposal: does Curve want to start that discussion?”
Tags
Dao
Related Posts
As Yearn.Finance’s yield vaults grow, ‘crop’ projects define boundaries
With millions and even billions of dollars at stake, industrial-scale yield farming is leading to pockets of resistance as some projects refuse to be left with the chaff. In the past week, team members from no-loss lottery project PoolTogether and exchange liquidity pool provider Curve Finance have proposed ways to reduce the load Yearn.Finance strategies place on their protocols and governance tokens. In a Tweet on Sunday, PoolTogether co-founder Leighton Cusack noted that Yearn has become the primary beneficiary of many of the protocol’s DAI lotteries, as Yearn controls 57% of all DAI funds ($27 million of the $47 million …
Ethereum / June 15, 2021
Got crypto? Here are 3 debit cards that let you spend your stack
As blockchain technology and the public's awareness of cryptocurrency continues to grow, a range of new use cases a coming to market and enhancing the efficacy of legacy financial systems. Despite its many applications, the original use case for Bitcoin (BTC) as a medium of exchange remains one of the most fundamental applications of blockchain technology and while BTC might not be the best asset to use for payments, there are service providers who have eased the process of settling transactions in other cryptocurrencies. For now, the most widely accepted way to use cryptocurrencies for direct payments in everyday life …
Blockchain / April 30, 2021
Ethfinex Launches DAO as Executives Consider Regulatory Landscape
Cryptocurrency exchange Ethfinex, the sister exchange of Bitfinex, has launched a test decentralized autonomous organization (DAO), the company confirmed in a blog post on June 12. Ethfinex — which earlier this month launched a decentralized over-the-counter (OTC) trading platform — said it wants to decentralize control of its operations. The DAO was built by DAOstack and is known as efxDAO, with an initial funding budget of $5,000. “Today we reach an important milestone in our path to decentralised governance of Ethfinex,” the exchange’s community lead, Ben Wilson, wrote in the blog post. Wilson added: “We have collaborated with decentralisation protocol …
Ethereum / June 13, 2019
Coinbase Now Supports Cryptocurrency Token EOS
Major United States-based cryptocurrency exchange and wallet service Coinbase has added support for EOS, according to a press release on May 30. The new addition is reportedly available for trading and storage in most areas covered by Coinbase, with the exception of the United Kingdom and New York at press time. The announcement also notes that there are no transaction fees associated with EOS; the cost is instead paid in computing resources, such as a tax on RAM, CPUs, or network bandwidth. Users that run the network also earn EOS by contributing to the computational power needed to run transactions. …
Decentralization / May 30, 2019
Vitalik Buterin reveals 3 ‘huge’ opportunities for crypto in 2023
Ethereum co-founder Vitalik Buterin has shared three “huge" opportunities yet to be realized in crypto, including mass crypto wallet adoption, inflation-resistant stablecoins, and Ethereum-powered website logins. During an interview with Bankless co-owner David Hoffman, Buterin shared his outlook for the crypto industry in 2023, responding to Hoffman’s raised concern that the “adoption wave” for decentralized applications is now over and that there’s “less opportunity” for developers to come in and build new decentralized applications. Buterin instead shrugged off the “limbo period” that Hoffman eluded to, firstly suggesting that more developments need to be made on cryptocurrency wallet infrastructure in order …
Adoption / Dec. 20, 2022