US Fed researcher says CBDCs should beat Big Tech payments on privacy protection

Published at: Nov. 23, 2020

Cash use has lost a ton of ground to digital payments as the pandemic has changed the way people transact worldwide. Some experts have recently argued that central bank digital currencies, or CBDCs, could solve the problem of leaving that payments data in the hands of major tech platforms.

In a blog post published Monday morning, Federal Reserve of New York researcher Michael Lee and University of California Santa Barbara economics professor Rod Garratt expounded on a paper they released earlier this month.

The authors point to tech firms' troubling use of consumer data, which has landed everyone from Visa to Facebook in trouble for potential antitrust violations. The blog post says:

"Transactions using digital payments enable firms to capture consumers’ personal data; cash does not. Data are not shared between firms. By gaining exclusive access to data from their own customers, firms may use this information to gain a competitive edge."

A CBDC, the researchers suggest, is the best successor to cash in terms of efficiency and consumer protection in the digital age. While the post mentions cryptocurrencies as a separate alternative to bigger payment platforms, it does not explicitly advocate distributed ledger technology for a CBDC. It does, however, say a CBDC would be cheaper and more eco-friendly:

"Privacy-preserving digital payment alternatives, such as cryptocurrencies, involve high transaction costs and can be environmentally costly. Private initiatives proposed by 'BigTech' firms are likely to lead to even less privacy."

Research into CBDCs has been accelerating. Interest initially soared at the beginning of the pandemic, and now, major central banks and financial institutions are busy churning out investigations into what needs to change for various jurisdictions to digitize their money.

Among the world's largest economies, many see China as the leader in the CBDC race. Others, however, argue that this is because the Chinese government does not care about discussing privacy features for a digital yuan, which will ultimately become a tool of surveillance.

Lee had not responded to Cointelegraph's request for comment as of the time of publication.

Tags
Related Posts
Trump bans Chinese payment apps, including AliPay and WeChat Pay
With just two weeks left in office, President Donald Trump has sent out a new executive order targeting Chinese payment apps. The Tuesday order bars United States citizens or people located in the U.S. from using nine Chinese payment apps. It continues the White House's earlier efforts to cut off the U.S. market from Chinese-owned apps like TikTok. Yesterday's order repeats earlier concerns of data collection by the Chinese Communist Party: "The continuing activity of the PRC and the CCP to steal or otherwise obtain United States persons’ data makes clear that there is an intent to use bulk data …
Regulation / Jan. 6, 2021
Bank for International Settlements Calls CBDCs a Potential ‘Sea Change’
In advance of its coming annual report, on June 24 the Bank for International Settlements released a special chapter from that report on digital payments — especially central bank digital currencies, a topic that’s attracted tremendous interest in recent months. The report encourages central banks to treat CBDCs as their future, saying: “One option at the frontier of policy opportunities is the issuance of CBDCs, which could amount to a sea change.” A recent shift in favor of CBDCs The BIS found that there had been a major bullish shift in sentiment for CBDCs since the beginning of this year …
Regulation / June 24, 2020
Law Decoded: Cents and stability, Nov. 20–27
Editor’s note As many of you were certainly following in real time, a bull market gave way to a bloodbath yesterday, which happened to be Thanksgiving in the United States. Personally, I’ve never thought that Bitcoin’s (BTC) price was any sort of proof of its value proposition, but for many, its retreat yesterday certainly dashed many a planned gloat to family members more receptive to massive gains than concepts like censorship resistance. But obviously, volatility is part of the game with cryptocurrencies. One of the more prominent solutions to this problem has been the rise of stablecoins, especially following the …
Regulation / Nov. 27, 2020
United States CBDC would ‘crowd out’ crypto ecosystem: Ex-Biden advisor
The creation of a United States digital dollar would “crowd out” the cryptocurrency ecosystem and protect the national security of the U.S. according to a former top advisor in president Joe Biden’s administration. Daleep Singh — a former Deputy National Security Advisor for International Economics in the Biden administration — made the comments at a Feb. 28 Senate Banking Committee hearing, suggesting that cryptocurrencies facilitate ransomware attacks and contribute to the evasion of U.S. sanctions. Singh believes the U.S. government embracing a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) “is the single best step that we could take [to protect national interests] …
Regulation / March 1, 2023
China’s central bank worried about stablecoins’ risk to financial systems
The Chinese central bank is “quite worried” about the global financial risks associated with digital currencies, particularly stablecoins, according to a senior official. Fan Yifei, a deputy governor of the People’s Bank of China (PBoC), expressed concerns over the reportedly serious threat stablecoins, such as Tether (USDT), pose to global financial and settlement systems, CNBC reported on Thursday. The official emphasized that the speed of development in private payments systems is “very alarming,” and the PBoC is working against monopolies and the “disorderly expansion of capital,” adding: “Some commercial organizations’ so-called stablecoins, especially global stablecoins, may bring risks and challenges …
Bitcoin / July 8, 2021