Libra Hearing Fails to Assuage Senior Lawmakers' Concerns

Published at: Oct. 24, 2019

Following testimony before the United States House of Representatives Financial Services Committee earlier today, lawmakers are still concerned about the possible launch of the Libra stablecoin.

On Oct. 23, legislators heard statements from Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg and posed questions covering a variety of topics from Libra to Facebook's data policies and reaction to possible foreign influences on the platform. 

Following the hearing, the committee's chair, Maxine Waters, told Cointelegraph, "I don't support Libra at all at this point." Waters added:

"And it's not as if I support it if it does this or if it does that. At this point, I am not a supporter of Libra. I don't know what it is, I don't think that that has been adequately explained."

She went on to say, "I don't think that he [Zuckerberg] should be moving forward with this huge project — this big idea, with all these other concerns that have not really been resolved."

Proponents say prohibition could stifle innovation

A number of representatives on the Financial Services Committee stated that not acting fast on Libra could lead to the U.S. being left behind and losing its spot as a global leader in finance and innovation. Rep. Patrick McHenry began his comments by declaring, “Today is a trial on American innovation.”

Specifically, the Facebook founder noted that China was working on a digital version of its national currency that, should it come to fruition before a dollar-backed project like Libra, could threaten the economic and geopolitical position of the U.S., he claimed. 

Zuckerberg also said, "The financial industry is stagnant. There is no digital financial architecture to support the innovation that we need. [...] I don’t know if Libra is going to work, but I believe in trying new things.”

In her statements after the hearing, Waters noted that she supports innovation, but first needs to know what the project is and how it operates before the government gives the green light to the Libra Association, which could manage a potentially staggering amount of wealth. 

The Department of the Treasury is monitoring Libra

In a separate hearing yesterday, Secretary of the Treasury Steven Mnuchin stated that the Financial Stability Oversight Council (FSOC), which operates under the Treasury's purview, has created a working group to monitor cryptocurrencies and Libra. 

Mnuchin added that participant institutions in the Libra Association may be one avenue through which the FSOC regulates the project.

Tags
Related Posts
Stablecoins present new dilemmas for regulators as mass adoption looms
Stablecoins present peculiar challenges to regulators. Although there is no single, agreed-upon definition of a stablecoin, the common denominator of the commonly used definitions is that stablecoins are designed to maintain a stable value in relation to a specified currency, asset or pool of such currencies/assets. They are contrasted with regular cryptocurrencies, which have no such stability mechanism and whose values tend to fluctuate, sometimes even substantially. Related: All risk, no gain? The vague definition of stablecoins is causing problems Stablecoins do not denote a uniform category but represent a variety of crypto instruments that can vary significantly in legal, …
Technology / May 9, 2021
Blockchain, Not Crypto, Is at Core of Facebook’s Libra, Vice Chair Says
Despite existing concerns that blockchain is not mature enough to bring the new era of payments, the technology is being increasingly explored by global central banks. Blockchain technology meanwhile remains at the core of Facebook’s digital currency Libra, according to a top project executive. Since Libra’s white paper release in June 2019, the not-yet-launched stablecoin has continued to rely on blockchain architecture, Libra Association’s vice chair Dante Disparte explained. Blockchain unlocks payment network interoperability In an April 28 interview with financial publication Central Banking, Disparte outlined a number of structural benefits provided by blockchain implementation. As part of the blockchain-powered …
Blockchain / April 28, 2020
Obama's Under Secretary for Terrorism Appointed CEO of Libra
May 6, the Libra Association announced the appointment of Obama’s former under secretary for terrorism as its first CEO. Stuart Levey served as an under secretary for terrorism under the administrations of George W. Bush and Barack Obama, focusing on the enforcement of all U.S. anti-money laundering and counter terrorist financing laws by the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN). In his most recent position, he served as the chief legal officer at HSBC. Levey’s appointment continues a trend of Libra trying to make peace with regulators. Bipartisan support The press release quotes Katie Haun, General Partner at Andreessen Horowitz and …
Regulation / May 6, 2020
US Congresswoman Vows to Brand Facebook’s Libra a Security Despite Today’s Updates
A United States congresswoman has said that she will keep working to brand Facebook’s planned stablecoin Libra a security. Facebook and the Libra Association may well have to deal with the SEC In an April 16 announcement, Representative Sylvia Garcia (D-TX) denied that recent updates to Libra’s whitepaper had substantively changed the yet-to-be-released stablecoin’s status as a security. Garcia contends that the newly proposed version of Libra still derives value from a “basket of currencies” subject to change from the Libra Association, which hangs the value of the coin on the work of a third party i.e. a security under …
Regulation / April 16, 2020
Privacy or policy? Why Facebook's crypto wallet Novi is facing resistance
The stablecoin market has grown exponentially over the last few months due to the numerous advantages blockchain-based versions of fiat currencies have. But, when Facebook launched its cryptocurrency wallet Novi using Paxos’ stablecoin, some United States senators were quick to oppose it. Are they concerned about user data or monetary sovereignty? The social media giant which, according to its Q2 2021 report, has 2.9 billion monthly active users across all of its platforms, tapped Coinbase and Paxos for its Novi digital wallet project that kicked off its testing phase in the U.S. and Guatemala on Oct. 19. The pilot program …
Technology / Oct. 27, 2021