U.S. lawmakers argue SEC accounting policy places crypto customers at risk

Published at: March 3, 2023

Two United States lawmakers have criticized crypto accounting guidelines outlined by the securities regulator, arguing it places crypto customers at greater risk of loss.

The guidelines came from the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), which became effective in April last year.

The guidelines ask financial companies holding crypto for customers to recognize all digital assets they do not control as a liability. It also states that digital assets should be backed by a safeguarding asset.

Crypto companies must show liabilities equal to ALL customer crypto assets, according to SEC's new rule SAB 121 issued in March 2022.@coinbase complied for their Q2 filing and now shows an $88B "customer crypto liabilities" item. https://t.co/59029Pr2LE

— Cory Swan.com #Bitcoin WORKS (@coryklippsten) August 15, 2022

However, Senator Cynthia Lummis and Representative Patrick McHenry argued on Mar. 2 that these guidelines will “likely” discourage regulated entities from engaging in digital asset custody, which is the opposite effect of what the regulator should be doing. 

In a letter to ranking individuals from the Federal Reserve System, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation  (FDIC) and the National Credit Union Administration, the lawmakers argued that while Staff Accounting Bulletin (SAB) 121 was intended to provide clarity on accounting treatment for digital assets, it carried negative side effects, claiming:

“SAB 121 places customer assets at greater risk of loss if a custodian becomes insolvent or enters receivership, violating the SEC’s fundamental mission to protect customers.”

The lawmakers argue the effect of SAB 121 will be to “deny millions of Americans access to safe and secure custodial arrangements for digital assets.”

"In sum, the effect of SAB 121 is to deny millions of Americans access to safe and secure custodial arrangements for digital assets."⬇️⬇️ My letter with @PatrickMcHenry here:https://t.co/kEQKJMg4tC

— Senator Cynthia Lummis (@SenLummis) March 2, 2023

The lawmakers also disagreed with the “breadth of the ‘digital asset’ definition in SAB 121,” arguing that “a more nuanced hierarchy for this asset class which considers the opportunities and risks of digital assets with different functions is necessary.”

Related: SEC chair implies crypto exchanges may not be ‘qualified custodians’ as new rule is drafted

Lawmakers including Lummis have kicked up a fuss over the SEC accounting bulletin in the past.

Last year, five Republican Senators, including Lummis, sent a letter to the SEC on Jun. 16, sharing their concern that the bulletin amounted to “regulation disguised as staff guidance” and did not adhere to the Administrative Procedure Act.

SEC commissioner Hester Peirce shared similar concerns on Mar. 31, soon after the bulletin was released, noting it was “the way the change is being made” rather than the accounting determination itself she took issue with, which she characterized as:

“Yet another manifestation of the Securities and Exchange Commission’s scattershot and inefficient approach to crypto.”
Tags
Regulation
Sec
Business
Digital Asset
Coinbase
Banking
Banks
Related Posts
Future of finance: US banks partner with crypto custodians
Grayscale Investments’ latest report “Reimagining the Future of Finance” defines the digital economy as “the intersection of technology and finance that’s increasingly defined by digital spaces, experiences, and transactions.” With this in mind, it shouldn’t come as a surprise that many financial institutions have begun to offer services that allow clients access to Bitcoin (BTC) and other digital assets. Last year, in particular, saw an influx of financial institutions incorporating support for crypto-asset custody. For example, Bank of New York Mellon, or BNY Mellon, announced in February 2021 plans to hold, transfer and issue Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies as an …
Decentralization / Feb. 20, 2022
Coinbase seeks new exec to debate with policymakers
Coinbase is looking for a new hire to manage the exchange’s sour relationship with policymakers. The United States-based crypto exchange aims to swell its legal and compliance team ranks. The company is looking for more than 350 new hires, with 24 job openings within the legal and compliance team. More specifically, Coinbase is seeking a new manager to oversee communications with U.S. policymakers. Along with a strong network in Washington D.C, Coinbase expects its new U.S. policy communications manager, who would lead its media relations and strategic presence in critical policy debates, to have “excellent political judgment.” Better communication with …
Regulation / Sept. 23, 2021
JPMorgan Provides Banking Services to Crypto Exchanges Coinbase and Gemini
JPMorgan Chase, the United States’ largest bank, has reportedly taken on U.S. cryptocurrency exchanges Coinbase and Gemini as customers. A report from the Wall Street Journal on May 12 cited unnamed sources apparently familiar with the matter, who highlighted that the move is the first time the banking giant has served clients from the crypto industry. Both exchange accounts were reportedly accepted in April, with transactions now starting to be processed, sources told the WSJ. JPMorgan Chase is not processing Bitcoin (BTC) or other cryptocurrency transactions on behalf of the exchanges but is providing cash-management services and handling dollar transactions …
Adoption / May 12, 2020
Fed denies Custodia Bank application to join the Federal Reserve System
The Federal Reserve Board has rejected Custodia Bank’s application to become a member of the Federal Reserve System. In its announcement, the Fed stated that the application was “inconsistent with the required factors under the law.” It also claimed Custodia had an “insufficient” management framework and cited an earlier joint declaration by the Fed with the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation and Office of the Comptroller of the Currency that found crypto assets to be at odds with sound banking practices. STATEMENT FROM CUSTODIA BANK about today's Federal Reserve action on its membership application. Its master account application remains pending: pic.twitter.com/QkMjcT508J …
Regulation / Jan. 27, 2023
Getting rid of crypto staking would be a 'terrible path' for the US — Coinbase CEO
The CEO and co-founder of cryptocurrency exchange Coinbase, Brian Armstrong, believes that banning retail crypto staking in the United States would be a ‘terrible’ move by the country's regulators. Armstrong made the comments in a Feb. 9 Twitter thread which has already been viewed over 2.2 million times, after noting they've heard “rumors” that the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission “would like to get rid of crypto staking” for retail customers. “I hope that's not the case as I believe it would be a terrible path for the U.S. if that was allowed to happen.” Armstrong did not share where …
Regulation / Feb. 9, 2023