Coinbase seeks extended feedback deadline to FinCEN’s new crypto rules

Published at: Dec. 22, 2020

Coinbase, one of the largest cryptocurrency exchanges in the United States, is advocating extension for the industry’s feedback deadline to newly proposed crypto rules by the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, or FinCEN.

In a Dec. 21 blog post, Coinbase’s chief legal officer Paul Grewal addressed FinCEN’s newly released rulemaking regarding self-hosted crypto wallets. The blog post represents an open letter to Kenneth Blanco, the director of FinCEN.

In the letter, Grewal considered the new rules by the Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, as an “unfortunate and disappointing departure” from the company’s long-running relationship with the regulator.

Grewal elaborated that the 15-day period granted by FinCEN to the industry to respond to the new rules is not enough, especially given that it is spanning Christmas holidays and comes amid the COVID-19 pandemic:

“FinCEN asked the public to provide comments in just 15 days, spanning Christmas Eve, Christmas Day, New Year’s Eve, and New Year’s Day, in the middle of a global pandemic — leaving just a handful of actual working days for comments.”

As such, Coinbase’s legal executive asked FinCEN to “reconsider its haste” and provide a typical 60-day period notice-and-comment for the proposed rulemaking. Grewal noted that 60-day comment periods to regulations represent an ordinary practice by FinCEN in terms of the traditional financial industry. “For example, FinCEN’s Customer Due Diligence Requirements for Financial Institutions provided the traditional 60 days for notice and comment,” Grewal noted.

The exec went on to say that an extended notice-and-comment period will provide the industry with a “true opportunity to engage in the review and comment process with respect to the proposed rule as the law requires.” Grewal wrote:

“There is no emergency here [...] There is also no justification for treating the cryptocurrency industry so differently from our counterparts in traditional finance. [...] The same rationale applies even more so in the midst of a global pandemic.”

Previously, major industry figures like Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire criticized the new rules, appealing for regulators to collaborate with the industry in adopting crypto regulations. Several members of Congress including representatives Warren Davidson and Tom Emmer also opposed the rumored ban on self-hosted crypto wallets on Dec. 9.

Tags
Related Posts
Powers On... Broker disintermediation and unregulated crypto exchanges cause major concerns
Powers On... is a monthly opinion column from Marc Powers, who spent much of his 40-year legal career working with complex securities-related cases in the United States after a stint with the SEC. He is now an adjunct professor at Florida International University College of Law, where he teaches the course “Blockchain, Crypto and Regulatory Considerations.” More and more, governments are fearing that they will lose control over aspects of their respective legitimate financial systems, including capital raising and trading, to the hundreds of unlicensed, unregulated centralized and decentralized crypto exchanges worldwide. There is a clear rising chorus of alarm …
Technology / Aug. 24, 2021
Jack Dorsey warns that FinCEN regulations will drive crypto users offshore
Major U.S crypto firms are rallying against FinCEN’s proposed regulations that would force businesses operating with crypto to gather information on the identities of non-customer counterparties. A Jan. 4 letter from Jack Dorsey, CEO of financial services firm Square takes aim at the proposal for seeking to impose reporting obligations that go “far beyond what is required for cash transactions,” and that Sqaure would be expected to collect “unreliable data about people who have not opted into our service or signed up as our customers.” “Counterparty name and address collection/reporting should not be required for [virtual currency] CTRs or recordkeeping, …
Regulation / Jan. 5, 2021
Heavy hitters of crypto call for users to comment on proposed FinCEN wallet rule
A number of players are encouraging individuals to speak out against FinCEN’s new crypto rules before comments close next week. Crypto exchange Coinbase and the foundation behind Monero are the latest firms to join in calling for crypto users to share their thoughts on the U.S. Treasury's Financial Crimes Enforcement Network’s new rules. In a blog post today, Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong said the proposal would represent “too big of an intrusion” on users’ privacy, stating that crypto exchanges would need to collect and share names and addresses for anyone sending or receiving more than $3,000 in crypto in a …
Regulation / Dec. 30, 2020
Major Crypto Exchanges Lament Outsized Scrutiny From US IRS
Representatives of major crypto exchanges today told the United States Internal Revenue Service that they want to see clear regulations rather than vague suspicion from the tax authority. In a March 3 panel that is a continuation of a broader crypto summit at the IRS building in Washington, D.C., representatives from Coinbase, Kraken, and major accounting firm RSM US LLP argued that the crypto world had experienced outsized scrutiny from regulators compared to its size and darkness. U.S. crypto exchanges say they aren’t that scary The representatives from Coinbase — head of global tax information reporting Sulolit Mukherjee — and …
Regulation / March 3, 2020
House committee announces crypto CEOs will testify at Dec. 8 hearing on digital assets
Maxine Waters, the chair of the House Committee on Financial Services, has announced several chief executive officers at major crypto firms in the United States will speak at a hearing to discuss digital assets and the future of finance. According to a Wednesday announcement, Waters said Circle CEO Jeremy Allaire, FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried, Bitfury CEO Brian Brooks, Paxos CEO Chad Cascarilla, Stellar Development Foundation CEO Denelle Dixon, and Alesia Haas, the CEO of Coinbase Inc. and the CFO of Coinbase Global, will be witnesses at a full House committee hearing held on Dec. 8. The hearing, named Digital Assets …
Regulation / Dec. 1, 2021