India’s Former Finance Secretary Spars With Industry Experts on Crypto Ban

Published at: July 17, 2020

During a webinar on July 17, the former Finance Secretary of India, Subhash Chandra Garg, discussed cryptocurrencies with Indian industry leaders including Nischal Shetty, the CEO of Indian crypto exchange WazirX, and Siddharth Sogani, the founder of blockchain research company Crebaco.

In 2019, Garg along with his secretariat drafted a bill that proposed a ban on cryptocurrencies along with a 10-year jail term and a fine of up to 25 crore rupees (~$3.3 million) for anyone who issued, used or held these assets.

Opening a dialogue with the industry

Today was the first time Garg discussed the issue with members of the crypto industry, allowing the former Secretary to clarify a longstanding perception that the proposed bill was to completely eradicate crypto assets from the Indian financial ecosystem.

Garg said that he approves of the use of crypto-assets as regulated commodities but added that they must not be allowed to function as currencies in India.

In Garg’s opinion, there is no issue with anyone presenting a “computer code” as a digital asset and with people wanting to invest in it. But in that way, he said, crypto is more of a tradable commodity and not a currency, and it should be regulated from the same viewpoint.

He also insisted that private crypto assets as currencies have no justification to exist and must be outlawed.

Time to digitize currencies but without crypto

Sharing his thoughts on the digitization of money, Garg said that the way we perceive and use money has changed largely over time. Today, the digitization of money and the creation of a central bank digital currency is part of an overall need to deliver better financial services, he noted.

There are several ways the Indian government could digitize the rupee, he stated, and crypto assets based on distributed ledger technology were only one of those ways. However, he strongly disapproved of digitizing money using crypto assets and rather preferred the use of dematerialized notes, saying:

“The way cryptocurrency works is on the distributed ledger technology. It’s a high investment technology. It can never be a common man’s currency.”

Crypto proponents answer

While Garg found no logical reason for the existence and use of crypto assets, he showed a strong attraction to distributed ledger technology, stating that it has many promising use cases in the financial landscape.

To that end, WazirX’s Nischal Shetty said crypto assets are important for pushing forward blockchain innovation. Sharing the example of deploying a code on the Ethereum blockchain, he explained to Garg that doing so requires a developer to make a payment in Ether (ETH), which is a cryptocurrency.

These payments cannot be made in the Indian rupee, he stated. Thus, cryptocurrencies should not be seen as a replacement for the rupee but as a form of alternative payment in places one cannot use traditional money.

He also mentioned the importance of cryptocurrencies in micropayments, loans and other financial verticals.

Reflecting on the newness of the technology, Crebaco’s Siddharth Sogani said that blockchain and cryptocurrencies are a new technology and that every bit of knowledge “is derived by practical experience, not by a set of books.”

Sogani concluded that the government should not ban cryptos out of fear, but rather should strive to understand the technology and help it grow.

Tags
Regulation
Cryptocurrencies
Ban
India
Assets
Related Posts
Indian Banks Act Slow to Accept Crypto Industry Despite RBI’s Approval
The repeal of a blanket ban on cryptocurrencies in March by India’s central bank, the Reserve Bank of India, has been a boon to the thriving crypto industry in India — with the launch of new exchanges being a catalyst. This is despite the country being one of the most severely affected nations by the COVID-19 pandemic, which has led to a deepening economic crisis across the nation. For investors and fintech innovators alike, cryptocurrency and blockchain technology have proven to be a much-needed respite in these challenging times. Regulatory uncertainty Repealing the blanket ban was not the ultimate solution …
Blockchain / June 27, 2020
Indian Government Again Proposes Blanket Ban on Cryptocurrencies
The Indian Ministry of Finance has proposed to legally ban cryptocurrencies within the subcontinent. With this, the Indian crypto community is met with yet another unexpected turn. The proposal will first be sent to the Union Council of Ministers and then be forwarded to the parliament for final review. The Economic Times report quoted a senior government official: “A note has been moved (by the finance ministry) for inter-ministerial consultations.” Only three months ago, the Supreme Court of India overruled the Reserve Bank of India’s ban on banks providing services to individuals and companies dealing in cryptocurrencies. A blow to …
Regulation / June 12, 2020
Law Decoded: India ponders going full China on crypto, Nov. 22–29
Are big emerging economies more likely to gravitate toward blanket crypto bans? China has set a precedent, and now it appears as if India could be weighing a similar policy direction: A bill containing a proposed ban on all “private cryptocurrencies” will go in front of the nation’s parliament sometime this winter. The measure is designed to clear the way for India’s central bank to advance its digital currency agenda. Whether a sovereign central bank digital currency can coexist with a thriving market of “private” cryptos will be one of the central questions of the looming CBDC age, and it …
Regulation / Nov. 29, 2021
Indian parliament's agenda includes crypto training session, leaves out bill banning digital assets
The latest bulletin covering the agenda for India's lower house of parliament includes “a lecture on understanding cryptocurrency” and its economic impact. According to a Monday publication from the Lok Sabha, the Parliamentary Research and Training Institute for Democracies group within the government has organized a training evening for lawmakers on Feb. 2 regarding crypto and its effects on the Indian economy. In addition, the legislative business calendar for the lower house of parliament no longer includes a bill which could potentially ban crypto in the country. The Cryptocurrency and Regulation of Official Digital Currency Bill does not appear as …
Regulation / Jan. 31, 2022
RBI seemingly wants to ban cryptocurrencies, but not for the reasons you might think
On Thursday, the Reserve Bank of India, or RBI, the country's central bank, published a critical bulletin regarding the cryptocurrency industry. While the report praised the innovative distributed ledger technology associated with digital currencies, the RBI dismissed arguments calling for regulation of such assets and called for an outright ban. RBI's core concerns were related to cryptocurrencies threatening the country's financial sovereignty. The RBI wrote: "Historically, private currencies have resulted in instability and therefore have evolved into fiat currencies over centuries. The retrograde step back to private currencies cannot be taken simply because technology allows it without considering the dislocation …
Adoption / March 17, 2022