Court victory precedent: IRS may not tax staking rewards until sold

Published at: Feb. 3, 2022

A Nashville couple’s lawsuit over taxes they paid on unclaimed and unsold Tezos staking rewards is coming to an end with the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) agreeing to issue them a refund.

The decision may set a precedent for future guidance on how crypto rewards earned through staking are taxed. At present Proof-of-Stake staking rewards are classified as income, with tax payable as they are gained. The new development suggests they should be only taxed when they are sold for USD.

The Jarretts filed a complaint against the United States government in May 2021 which stated that the 8,876 Tezos (XTZ) tokens they created in 2019 were not income and should not have been taxed as such. The complaint also claimed that the government was attempting to do something “unprecedented, which is tax creative activity rather than income.”

“Taxing newly created cakes, books, or tokens as income would have far-reaching and detrimental effects on taxpayers and the U.S. economy, and is without support in the Internal Revenue Code, regulations, caselaw, or the Constitution.”

According to court filings expected to be made public on Thursday the IRS declared it would follow through with the Jarretts’ request to refund with ”statutory interest as provided by the law” the $3,793 that the Jarretts paid for their unclaimed rewards last year.

As of yet, guidance on how to tax unclaimed staking rewards is lacking. The IRS asks taxpayers whether they have “received, sold, exchanged, or otherwise disposed of any financial interest in any virtual currency”, but none of those descriptors seem to pertain directly to the Jarretts’ unsold and unclaimed rewards.

Related: Crypto tax calculator CoinTracker valued at $1.3B following $100M raise

Forbes reported that sources close to the matter say the couple plans to pursue the case further in court to obtain longer-term protection and set a nationwide precedent. American taxpayers are likely praying that no legislative response to this court outcome resembles the U.K. regulator’s new guidance on crypto staking. There, staking crypto will often be considered as the sale of tokens and will incur capital gains tax.

Tags
Irs
Related Posts
PoS validator turns down IRS tax refund offer, pushes for clear policy on staking taxation
A United States couple suing the federal tax agency over Tezos (XTZ) staking rewards taxation chose to forego a tactical victory and engage in a court battle that could eventually result in policy change. Joshua and Jessica Jarrett, who run a node on the Tezos network (thus “baking” new blocks, in the ecosystem’s lingo), have sued the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) over the taxes paid on the XTZ tokens created in 2019. The Jarretts filed a refund claim on upwards of $3,000 paid on the tokens, which the IRS ignored. The fundamental point of contention underlying the lawsuit is the …
Regulation / Feb. 3, 2022
No precedent: IRS court settlement doesn't clarify crypto staking taxes
In May 2021, a Nashville couple known as the Jarretts filed a lawsuit against the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) over taxes they had paid on unclaimed and unsold Tezos (XTZ) staking rewards. At the beginning of February, news broke that the lawsuit filed by the Jarretts had come to an end, resulting in the IRS issuing the couple a tax refund for $3,793. Confusion among crypto holders Not long after this news made headlines, confusion among the crypto community piqued. One crypto media publication sent a tweet from its official account on Feb. 2, 2022, saying, “BREAKING: IRS …
Bitcoin / Feb. 8, 2022
Crypto tax ‘a top enforcement priority,’ reminds IRS Commissioner
The United States Internal Revenue Service continues to propose new tax reforms to regulate the crypto investments in the U.S., with the latest notice sharing tax obligations for the marijuana industry. The notice, signed by IRS Small Business/Self-Employed Division Commissioner De Lon Harris, reflects the priorities of the United States federal agency to ensure cryptocurrency tax compliance among local businesses that grow, distribute and sell cannabis. Commissioner Harris said that the use of cryptocurrencies in the cannabis industry is one of the top enforcement priorities of the IRS. The statement coincides with the recent proposal by the Senate lawmakers from …
Bitcoin / Sept. 28, 2021
Crypto couple tells court the IRS has no right to tax newly mined coins
A couple investing in crypto have claimed that coins gained by mining or staking are untaxable until sold, in a complaint filed to federal court. The Tennessee couple is seeking a refund from the United States Internal Revenue Service and filed a complaint with the U.S. District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee on Tuesday. Joshua and Jessica Jarrett claim that earnings from staking are not taxable transactions because they constitute the creation of property. They compared this to a baker making a cake or an author writing a novel. Law360 reported that the court heard Joshua Jarrett used …
Regulation / May 27, 2021
The IRS offers a $625,000 bounty to anyone who can break Monero and Lightning
The United States Internal Revenue Service has offered a bounty of up to $625,000 to anyone who can break purportedly untraceable privacy coins such as Monero (XMR) as well as trace transactions on Bitcoin’s (BTC) Lightning Network. The official proposal, published last week, says the IRS will accept submissions in the form of working prototypes until Sept. 16. If accepted, applicants will receive an initial payment of $500,000. This grant will allow applicants to develop their prototype into a working concept over the next eight months. Once the pilot test is completed and approved by the government, a further $125,000 …
Technology / Sept. 11, 2020